BCS 3.03: Jimmy in Jeopardy, Screw Chuck
Mar. 26th, 2025 09:39 pmI've written a few blogs already about minor character Mike in season 3 of Better Call Saul. While I've quipped that main character Saul hasn't appeared yet that's partly an amusing misdirection on my part.... Main character Jimmy McGill certainly has a story arc the first few episodes of season 3. It's just that he hasn't yet adopted his new name— the one we know from Breaking Bad and the one that's promised in the title of this show— Saul Goodman.
Jimmy's story in season 3 picks up from the season 2 finale, where Chuck tricked Jimmy into admitting on tape he tricked Chuck by falsifying documents. Chuck continues his manipulation of Jimmy— and other people— in 3.01 by tricking one of his company's legal assistants, into revealing information about the tape to Jimmy through Kim. Chuck, who if you recall was all high-and-mighty about "You hurt people, Jimmy, that's just what you do", seems to have absolutely no ethical problem with destroying other people's careers to punish Jimmy. He does this to provoke Jimmy into breaking into his house to steal the tape. He's so sure Jimmy will do it that he hires 24/7 security for his house, at his employer HHM's expense, to wait in his house to be witnesses when Jimmy makes his move.
In 3.02 Jimmy storms into Chuck's house demanding the tape. I caught myself talking back to the screen, "No, Jimmy, don't do that, it's wrong and it's a trap," but like teens in a horror movie following a trail of monster slobber around a blind corner, he does the stupid, self destructive thing anyway. It's part of his character that he's impulsive. And he's really pissed at Chuck for manipulating him into the confession.
Episode 3.03 picks up minutes after this. The police have been called to Chuck's house. Jimmy is being arrested. Jimmy, no stranger to what happens to criminal defendants when they're caught red-handed, goes outside to await his fate (handcuffs and a free ride in the back of a police car, followed by a night in jail) quietly. Chuck comes out to lecture him sanctimoniously:
Jimmy fires back at his brother:
I agree with Jimmy on this one. Though Jimmy did the crime and deserves to be punished, Chuck in his zeal to see Jimmy punished has completely discounted the years of sacrifice Jimmy made to help him. Chuck, as we've seen through various flashbacks up to this point in the series, has a lifetime of bitterness against Jimmy. He's bitter because he believes their parents loved Jimmy more than him despite him being the good son and Jimmy being the bad one. So yeah, fuck Chuck. He can die alone. In reality he'd be dead already from running those stupid propane lanterns inside his house.
Edited to add: In episode 3.05 Chuck refers to the legal maxim, Fiat justitia ruat caelum. Translated from Latin it means, "Let there be justice though the heavens fall." How ironic it is— how self-unaware Chuck is— that he espouses this philosophy when, through his monomaniacal zeal to punish Jimmy, it's the heavens he's pulling down on his own head.
Jimmy's story in season 3 picks up from the season 2 finale, where Chuck tricked Jimmy into admitting on tape he tricked Chuck by falsifying documents. Chuck continues his manipulation of Jimmy— and other people— in 3.01 by tricking one of his company's legal assistants, into revealing information about the tape to Jimmy through Kim. Chuck, who if you recall was all high-and-mighty about "You hurt people, Jimmy, that's just what you do", seems to have absolutely no ethical problem with destroying other people's careers to punish Jimmy. He does this to provoke Jimmy into breaking into his house to steal the tape. He's so sure Jimmy will do it that he hires 24/7 security for his house, at his employer HHM's expense, to wait in his house to be witnesses when Jimmy makes his move.
In 3.02 Jimmy storms into Chuck's house demanding the tape. I caught myself talking back to the screen, "No, Jimmy, don't do that, it's wrong and it's a trap," but like teens in a horror movie following a trail of monster slobber around a blind corner, he does the stupid, self destructive thing anyway. It's part of his character that he's impulsive. And he's really pissed at Chuck for manipulating him into the confession.
You taped me?! You asshole! [...] You pulled that heartstrings con job on me?! You piece of shit! "Oh, my brain used to work, I'm sick, I don't know what to do!" Asshole! No wonder Rebecca left you! What took her so long?!Jimmy finds the tape and destroys it. Coincidentally Chuck's law partner, Howard, is also there, hiding in the kitchen along with one of the private investigators Chuck hired to wait in his house. All three men are witnesses to Jimmy breaking in and destroying property.
Episode 3.03 picks up minutes after this. The police have been called to Chuck's house. Jimmy is being arrested. Jimmy, no stranger to what happens to criminal defendants when they're caught red-handed, goes outside to await his fate (handcuffs and a free ride in the back of a police car, followed by a night in jail) quietly. Chuck comes out to lecture him sanctimoniously:
Here's what's going to happen. The police will arrest you and I'm sorry, but I will be pressing charges. I told you there would be consequences. But I have to believe you'll face those consequences and you'll come out the other side a better man. I know it's hard to see right now. But Jimmy, this is an opportunity. That's why I'm doing this. Not to punish you. To show you... truly show you, that you have to make a change. Before it's too late. Before you destroy yourself. Or someone else. And I believe you can change. You'll find your path. And when you're ready... I will be there to help you walk that path.
Jimmy fires back at his brother:
Here's what's gonna happen. One day, you're gonna get sick again. One of your employees is gonna find you, curled up in that space-blanket, take you to the hospital, hook you up to those machines that beep and whir and hurt. And this time, it'll be too much. And you will die there. Alone.
I agree with Jimmy on this one. Though Jimmy did the crime and deserves to be punished, Chuck in his zeal to see Jimmy punished has completely discounted the years of sacrifice Jimmy made to help him. Chuck, as we've seen through various flashbacks up to this point in the series, has a lifetime of bitterness against Jimmy. He's bitter because he believes their parents loved Jimmy more than him despite him being the good son and Jimmy being the bad one. So yeah, fuck Chuck. He can die alone. In reality he'd be dead already from running those stupid propane lanterns inside his house.
Edited to add: In episode 3.05 Chuck refers to the legal maxim, Fiat justitia ruat caelum. Translated from Latin it means, "Let there be justice though the heavens fall." How ironic it is— how self-unaware Chuck is— that he espouses this philosophy when, through his monomaniacal zeal to punish Jimmy, it's the heavens he's pulling down on his own head.